~Hartigan's Dessert Menu~

Cake & Ice Cream Cakes 
              Your choice of chocolate or yellow cake~

• Small Fudge Cake... $39.99  serves 8-10                       (1 flavor)

• Large Fudge Cake... $49.99  serves 14-16                    (1-2 flavors)

• Cake Roll... $34.99 serves 6-8 (1-2 flavors + chocolate cake)

• Large Cake N' Ice Cream Cake...$52.99 
• serves 16-18  (1-2 flavors + ice cream or buttercream icing)

• 9 x 12 Sheetcake... $74.99  serves 24-30 (2 -3 flavors + ice cream or buttercream icing)

• 12 x 15 Sheetcake... $94.99  serves 40-50             (2 -3 flavors + ice cream or buttercream icing)

All Ice Cream Cakes 

• Small Fudge Round...$28.99  serves 6-8 
• ( 1 flavor of ice cream.)

• Large Fudge Round...$38.99  serves 12-14

• Large Cookies n' Cream Round... $42.99 serves 12-14

• Small All Ice Cream... $45.99   serves 12-14  (2 flavors ice cream)

• Large All Ice Cream...$55.99  serves 18-20 (2-3 flavors ice cream)

• 9x12 Ice Cream Sheet-cake... $74.99           24-30   (same info as above)

• 12x15 Ice Cream Sheet-cake... $94.99         40-50    (same info as above)

Ice Cream Pies
       $26.99  serves 6-8  graham or oreo cookie crust

• Turtle Pie... (chocolate oreo crust, praline pecan ice cream, caramel topping, fudge border,whip cream  & pecans.)
• Grasshopper Pie... (oreo crust, mint chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate drizzle & whipped cream.)
• Mud Pie... (graham cracker crust, mocha almond fudge ice cream, fudge topping, whipped cream & crushed nuts.)
• Cookies n' Cream Pie... (oreo crust, cookies n' cream ice cream, buttercream topping, oreo cookies & whipped cream.)
• Peanut Butter Cup Pie... ( oreo crust, elephant tracks ice cream, reeses peanut butter cups & butter cream border.)
• Yogurt Pies... (oreo crust & chocolate OR vanilla  soft-serve yogurt.)
• Create your own Pie... (your choice of ice cream, pie crust, & 2 toppings)

Individual Items

• Clown Cones........... $5.10
• Monster Cookies..... $5.99
• Decorated Fudge Cake Slices... $5.99
• Hartigan's Pint-Sized Pies... $5.99

              Ask about our seasonal desserts!

Cake Ordering Online 
All online cake orders should be sent AT LEAST 48 HOURS in advance. For all other cake orders, such as same day pick up, please call. We have a full display case and we will try hard to accommodate your needs. Thank you for your order.
Online Dessert Order Page

                              Famous Hartigan's Ice Cream Cakes!

The desserts we have are custom made and perfect for any celebration~


~Birthdays
~Anniversaries
~Halloween
 ~Thanksgiving
~Hanukkah
~Christmas
~Easter
~Mother's Day
~Father's Day
~4th Of July




We have cakes in stock at the store as well as the option to create your own kind of cake. This can be done in-store or call 847.491.1232. For an online order please submit your order 48 hours in advance. 
Thank you.

---

                                                                       We accept cash, check, debit and credit cards.
                                                                                             Thank you!